Against the Spiritual Turn: Marxism, Realism, and Critical by Sean Creaven

By Sean Creaven

The argument provided during this publication is that the hot ‘spiritual’ trajectory of Roy Bhaskar’s paintings, upon which he first embarked with the booklet of his From East to West, undermines the elemental achievements of his previous paintings. the matter with Bhaskar’s new philosophical process (Transcendental Dialectical severe Realism or just Meta-Reality), from the critical-realist Marxist viewpoint recommended right here, is that it marks either a departure from and a negation of the sooner issues of Bhaskar to strengthen a realist philosophy of technology and under-labour for an emancipatory materialist socio-historical technological know-how. The end-result is a meta-philosophy that is irrealist, speculative, under-theorized, internally self-contradictory, and which can't offer philosophical counsel to liberatory social practices. towards theist ontological logics extra as a rule (including the much more rational theism provided through Margaret Archer, Andrew Collier and Doug Porpora), the argument of this ebook is that the earth-bound materialist dialectics of the classical Marxist culture, and the naturalistic humanism those dialectics under-labour at the terrain of socio-historical being, provide a way more promising future of severe realist concept and for liberatory politics and ethics.

Show description

Read or Download Against the Spiritual Turn: Marxism, Realism, and Critical Theory PDF

Best eastern books

Freeing Tibet: 50 Years of Struggle, Resilience, and Hope

Credits Allen Ginsberg! His Beat quest crossed, in New Jersey, with Geshe Wangyal's Kalmyk refugees who based the 1st Tibetan Buddhist monastery in a storage. whereas Ginsberg's popularization of the dharma, repeated during this e-book, is famous, Wangyal and his Tibetan colleagues give you the different facet of a symbiotic dating among the counterculture and the institution of their fight to elevate not just attention yet cash and resistance in the occupied place of birth for the reason for freedom.

The faith to doubt : glimpses of Buddhist uncertainty

Stephen Batchelor was once born in Scotland, in 1953. He grew up in a humanist atmosphere along with his mom and brother in Watford, north west of London. After finishing his schooling at Watford Grammar university, he travelled overland to India in 1972, on the age of eighteen. He settled in Dharamsala, the capital-in-exile of the Dalai Lama, and studied on the Library of Tibetan Works and information.

Extra info for Against the Spiritual Turn: Marxism, Realism, and Critical Theory

Example text

42 Here I briefly argued for ontological materialism on the grounds that the practical refutation of idealism during the history of scientific advance (in the sense that God has been shown to be superfluous to a rational and empirically testable knowledge of all processes or laws) … has forced its allegiants to make their appeal to a ‘final instance’ of undetermined creation beyond current knowledge and therefore outside the reach of rational criticism. Now, one should always be suspicious of ‘final instances’ which base their authority not on firm scientific knowledge (albeit provisional and incomplete) but on its … absence.

In a sense, they are published contributions to academic debates, since these are stored in public archives. Those who make these contributions to discussion lists do so in the full knowledge that these are open to discussion and disputation, and this normally encourages their authors to avoid offering ill-considered or unsupported judgements. Since it is regarded as perfectly acceptable in academic circles to draw citations from or respond critically to, for example, data derived from interviewing leading academics (and such interview data is also off-the-cuff), there seems no good reason to make an exception in the case of written contributions to academic discussion lists.

Moreover, I wish to argue that, by constructing their own ‘rationalized’ version of Christianity, the CR spiritualists mystify the real and essential nature of popular and institutional religiosity, which is not and cannot be a creature of reason, and which is politically and ethically problematic in a number of ways. Since Hartwig’s realist agnosticism (which allows the rational assertability of metaphysical idealism) rests its case on the impossible ideal of infallible knowledge,49 and since this realist agnosticism obviously stands or falls with the defensibility or otherwise of ontological idealism, this gives us ‘good enough’ (albeit fallible) reasons for accepting a thoroughgoing materialism as the ontological foundation of critical social theory and politics.

Download PDF sample

Rated 4.52 of 5 – based on 29 votes